Caffeinated Thoughts – Is Iowa’s Investment in Pre-K Education Worthwhile?
In this article by Shane Vander Hart at Caffeinated Thoughts, Dr. Effrem makes several statements about the ineffectiveness and invasiveness of government preschool programs in the context of the release of Iowa’s new early childhood standards:
“Having state defined preschool content standards, especially that include controversial social-emotional skills and attitudes like gender roles and family structure diversity, is a major usurpation of parental rights and family autonomy. Because Iowa’s and every other state’s preschool standards are mandated by the federal Head Start Act, they are also unconstitutional under the Tenth Amendment,” Dr. Karen Effrem, President of Education Liberty Watch, stated.
Effrem referred to a randomized control trial of Tennessee’s voluntary pre-school program by Vanderbilt University researchers that showed that academic gains achieved by students in Tennessee pre-K classrooms began to fade out by first grade and reversed by second and third grade. Researchers also noted more disciplinary infractions and special education placements by third-grade than students who did not enroll in pre-school…
…Effrem noted that there is much research that demonstrates not only does pre-K programs lack long-term academic benefits, but that short-term benefits fade and pre-K students have behavioral and academic setbacks.
“The emotional harm is particularly concerning and ironic, because preschool is the grade level that has had social-emotional standards in every state and for the longest period of time. Research also shows that it is early academic and attention skills, not social-emotional skills, that are most predictive of long-term academic achievement, but also shows that children who are allowed to play and creatively explore do much better than those subjected to standardized learning at this age,” Effrem said.
“The best thing that Iowa could do for the state’s children and families is to get rid of these standards and rote, mechanized learning and let them be kids,” Effrem added.
Video Interview – Dangers of School-based Mental Screening
Randy Osborne of Florida Government Watch did a second interview of Dr. Effrem regarding the dangers of school mental health screening which was also covered during the July 11th School Safety Commission meeting. None of the problems of inaccuracy, privacy invasion, consent, etc. were discussed by witness, Dr. Mark Olfson, the director of the failed TeenScreen program at Columbia University that shut down in 2012 without explanation after a school was sued for screening a teenager without parental consent. Dr. Effrem was an expert witness in that case.
The Co-director of TeenScreen, Dr. David Schaffer, admitted that TeenScreen has a false positive rate of 84%. Many of the other screening instruments have similarly and ridiculously poor accuracy rates. These screening instruments lead to rampant overprescribing of psychiatric medications that have dangerous and sometimes fatal side effects, including suicide and murderous rampages. It is extremely disturbing that there was no countervailing information presented at the commission meeting.
Video Interview – The Connection between Psychiatric Drugs and School Shootings No One wants to Talk About.
Thanks to Randy Osborne of Florida Government Watch for his excellent interview of Dr. Effrem on the dangerous connection between the rampant over-medicating of our youth and the increase in school and other mass shootings.
It is especially pertinent because this connection was severely and incorrectly minimized during the federal School Safety Commission meeting on July 11th.
The National Pulse – Congress Keeps Adding to the Education Swamp with Budget Increases
In this article, Dr. Effrem discusses the inability of congress to follow President Trump’s plan to downsize the Federal Department of Education and the statistics involved.
Although not surprising in an election year, congressional appropriators — who are generally not known for their political courage — are not doing anything to drain the putrid, unconstitutional swamp that is the U.S. Department of Education and its related programs. Both the full House and Senate Appropriations Committees have completed their Labor/HHS/Education appropriations bills for Fiscal Year (FY) 2019 that will begin October 1st.
Below is a detailed breakdown of the spending amounts for each of these programs, listed in millions of dollars.
PROGRAM | FY ’18 ENACTED | FY ’19 HOUSE Committee | FY ’19 SENATE Committee | FY ’19 WHITE HOUSE Proposed | HOUSE ’19 vs. WHITE HOUSE | HOUSE ’19 vs. ENACTED ’18 | SENATE ’19 vs. WHITE HOUSE | SENATE ’19 vs. ENACTED ’18 |
Title I for Disadvantaged Children | $16,443.8 | $16,443.8 | $16,568.8 | 15,926.8 | +$517 | $0 | +$642 | +$125 |
Student Support & Academic Enrichment (Including MH/SEL) | $1,100 | $1,200 | $1,225 | $0 | +$1,200 | +$100 | +$1,225 | +$125 |
21st Century Learning Centers | $1,211.7 | $1,211.7 | $1,211.7 | $0 | +$1,211.7 | $0 | +$1,211.7 | $0 |
Full Service Community Schools | $17.5 | $17.5 | $17.5 | $0 | +$17.5 | $0 | +$17.5 | $0 |
Institute for Education Sciences (Data Mining) | $613.5 | $613.5 | $615.5 | $521.6 | +$91.9 | $0 | +$93.9 | +$2 |
Head Start | $9,913 | $9,963 | $10,163 | $9,275 | +$638 | +$50 | +$888 | +$250 |
Preschool Dev. Grants | $250 | $250 | $250 | $0 | +$250 | $0 | +$250 | $0 |
Primary Health Care (Including Home Visits) | $1,626 | $1,526 | $1,526 | $5,091 | -$3,565 | -$100 | -$3,565 | -$100 |
State Assessments | $378 | $378 | $378 | $369 | $9 | $0 | $9 | $0 |
Charter Schools | $400 | $450 | $445 | $500 | -$50 | +$50 | -$45 | +$45 |
You can find the full article on the National Pulse website here.
Issues
- Assessments + Testing (25)
- Bullying/Sex Education (6)
- Child Protection League (2)
- Common Core Standards (78)
- Curriculum + Standards (65)
- Data Collection and Data Privacy (64)
- Early Education/Nanny State (75)
- Federal Education (128)
- International Education (6)
- LGBT Issues in Education (9)
- Media Appearances (4)
- PL/CBE (2)
- Planned Economy (11)
- Politics of Education (26)
- School Violence (9)
- Social Emotional Learning/Mental Health (52)
- State Education (89)
- Testimony/Presentations (17)
- Uncategorized (13)
- Unions (10)
Education Liberty Watch Projects
ELW Allies
- American Principles Project
- Cato Institute
- Conservative Teachers of America
- Constitutional Coalition
- Eagle Forum
- Minnesota Advocates and Champions for Children
- Missouri Education Watchdog
- Restore Oklahoma Parent Empowerment
- Stop Common Core
- The Pioneer Institute
- Truth in American Education
- What is Common Core – Education Without Representation